Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to The Mountain. We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Women in Combat
Topic Started: Nov 20 2007, 10:26 AM (575 Views)
Toothless Dawg
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
We have previously posted pictures of our young women serving our Country in battle zones. Gary had some fine women Marines in his unit (they were foxy chicks too), we had a picture of A1C Vanessa Dobos who was a gunner on a C130 gunship. Here is a picture of yet another woman in the thick of the fight.

Posted Image

Sgt Pierce is shown on patrol in the Graya'at area of Baghdads Adhamlyad District. You think a few years ago you would have seen a young Iraqi boy wearing the American flag on his t-shirt? Don't tell me we are losing!!!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Almtnman
Member Avatar
Administrator
Admin
I have nothing against women in combat or the military, but they should be reminded that if they do go to combat and by chance get captured, it's a whole different ballgame than if a man is captured.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Toothless Dawg
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
James,

I'm old school and still do not agree with women in combat. Although they have been there in every conflict since the revolutionary war in one capacity or another. It appears to being ramped up several notches in the WoT.

While you are quite correct in what you say, the way our society is brought up to respect and protect our women becomes a distraction when on the front. That said, there is nothing I can do about it so I will in turn support them along with the men in the military. They are apparently doing a bang-up job.

I know I'm getting old when I see the changes that have taken place in my short lifetime ... its a blast but sometimes I yearn for the old days which, for me shall not come again.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
California Redneck
Member Avatar
Full Member
[ *  * ]
I'm with you on women in combat. Don't even think they should be police officers or firemen unless they can pass the same physical fitness test as men.

I wish we could go back to the days before womens lib. Those skanks ruined it for women who enjoy being treated as a woman.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
legitlinda
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Toothless Dawg, I'm with you and CR on women in the military for all the reasons you stated. It just doesn't sit right with me.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Almtnman
Member Avatar
Administrator
Admin
Cheryl, your post reminded me of many years back when women started working at the steel mill that I did. The men had to quit letting it fly just anywhere like they had did for hundreds of years and go to the restroom. I was raised as TD says, the old school way. Anyway, I held the door open for one of those new women and she complained that I was trying to make her look inferior and said if I did it again that she would file a complaint against me. A few weeks passed and she was assigned a job of closing a steam valve on a 24 inch steam line. That's a pretty hard task to do and I walked by and she asked me for some help. I told her that I didn't want to make her feel inferior and that I was going to the break room for coffee. All that inferior hoola baloo ended after that.

BTW, I still hold doors open for the ladies. :)
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
legitlinda
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Almtnman, you are a true gentleman. :) I want to clarify my point of view as far as the work place goes. I think if a woman is capable of doing the job, and can carry her own weight, without jeopardizing the safety of herself or others, and do it in a timely manner, she should of course be able to considered for the job; on her merits, not her gender. Just look at my avatar of Rosie the Riveter....WE CAN DO IT! ;)
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
3006
Unregistered

I see nothing wrong with women in combat or the military.If that's where they want to be. They know what could happen.I'm all for women being all they want be,they are my equal no more no less.We just buried a young lady here in Dekalb this week end Full military honors. Ashley Sequra age 20 Army Health Care Specialist 708 Medical Company.A beautiful young woman and a exemplary Solder.
Quote Post Goto Top
 
California Redneck
Member Avatar
Full Member
[ *  * ]
3006, I am sorry to hear of this young soldier. I'm not saying women can't do the job in combat. I just have concerns that -- well, hell, women have hormonal ebbs and wanes, you know? Back in my days of suffering through this, I could be breathing fire one moment and crying my eyes out the next. Just no control over it. I don't think this is something men - except husbands??!! - are fully cognizant of. There's also the propensity of some men to look out for a woman. I'd hate like hell to know someone's loved one gave his life because of a woman on the battlefield. As was mentioned above, what those savages would do to a female combat soldier is too much to even think about. Not that I would want it to happen to a male, mind you.

AMM, good for you!!!! She deserved it. Glad to hear we have so many old school gentlemen here. I don't hang out with any man that doesn't treat me as a woman should be treated. Even my buddies!!

I'm with Linda, if a woman can do the job, and she is qualified, then go for it. I don't like, though, that work conditions change because a woman is present. Hell, I could out swear my ex and he was a Teamster!!!!!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Toothless Dawg
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Quote:
 
I don't think this is something men - except husbands??!! - are fully cognizant of.


CR,

Husband three times, boyfriend several times, old man a few times ... When I saw those 'symptoms' and 'felt the heat' I normally just headed for the Dawg House before getting kicked into it ... :lol: :lol: :lol:

Normally got on my knees too and thanked God for birthing me a male!!!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
nuzzlebunny
Unregistered

I imagine if enough men were bothering to sign up, women would be used in more traditional support roles like in the past.

I reckon these young women are currently doing the jobs able bodied young men do not wish to sign up for.
Quote Post Goto Top
 
Herb
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Over the years I have worked with/for and had women work for me. Overall I have not had any complaints with the women and their work.

There are special problems that arise when you have young, single men and women living and working in close proximity, 24/7. Talk about leadership challanges!!!! :thinking about it:

I do think that maybe it is a kind of physiological thing to be using them in combat in Iraq. Considering the way that feel about women, can you imagine the damage to their moral when they get their axse kicked by a woman????!!!! How much you want to bet the guy that is killed by a woman doesn't get his 70 (or is it 72, I can't keep track of their myths) virgins?

:garfield:
:jus-passin-thru:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
legitlinda
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Herb,Nov 20 2007
04:24 PM

I do think that maybe it is a kind of physiological thing to be using them in combat in Iraq. Considering the way that feel about women, can you imagine the damage to their moral when they get their axse kicked by a woman????!!!! How much you want to bet the guy that is killed by a woman doesn't get his 70 (or is it 72, I can't keep track of their myths) virgins?

Now that's the best reason I've heard for women in the military!!! :starwars:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Ali
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
I think it's wonderful that women are able to be whatever they want to be! And I still say 'thank you' to any man who holds a door open for me! I'm so proud of our women in uniform, so proud of the women who are at home with the kids when Dad is off to war. We are living in difficult times, and it takes all of us - together, to see that we don't spite our noses!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
greatwhiteelkhunter
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD! It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this. Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end. A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble. We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture. He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER! Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
nuzzlebunny
Unregistered

greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

Quote Post Goto Top
 
Herb
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
nuzzlebunny,Nov 21 2007
01:38 PM
greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

Note that it was about the FIRST 25 in the Iraqi army. Note that it didn't happen until 9/04. Had it ever happened before, NO. What did it take to get them the privilege to do this? How about the US overthrow of the repressive regime? How about the example that the women in the US forces set for the Iraqis?
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
nuzzlebunny
Unregistered

Herb,Nov 21 2007
04:43 PM
nuzzlebunny,Nov 21 2007
01:38 PM
greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

Note that it was about the FIRST 25 in the Iraqi army. Note that it didn't happen until 9/04. Had it ever happened before, NO. What did it take to get them the privilege to do this? How about the US overthrow of the repressive regime? How about the example that the women in the US forces set for the Iraqis?

I think having females in combat is great, as the US is finally practicing what it preaches in terms of gender equality in having them there. Leading by example is the best way to lead.

As far as the former regime goes, women were utilized in other ways....

From World Net Daily....

http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=19100
Quote Post Goto Top
 
greatwhiteelkhunter
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
nuzzlebunny,Nov 21 2007
01:38 PM
greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

When military are out doing the job they do (not in a staged event) and they interact with the common man and his family there is a very deep social status and family oneness that CAN'T be broken. Even just talking to a woman in public is nothing but TROUBLE! It's hard to do some jobs like checking the body for weapons at a check point as one example. What happens on the ground is different then what is reported and I think that is enough said about that!

We really HURT ourselves by breaking their social taboos and men talking to or looking at, Their woman is a TABOO!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
greatwhiteelkhunter
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
nuzzlebunny,Nov 22 2007
11:46 AM
Herb,Nov 21 2007
04:43 PM
nuzzlebunny,Nov 21 2007
01:38 PM
greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

Note that it was about the FIRST 25 in the Iraqi army. Note that it didn't happen until 9/04. Had it ever happened before, NO. What did it take to get them the privilege to do this? How about the US overthrow of the repressive regime? How about the example that the women in the US forces set for the Iraqis?

I think having females in combat is great, as the US is finally practicing what it preaches in terms of gender equality in having them there. Leading by example is the best way to lead.

As far as the former regime goes, women were utilized in other ways....

From World Net Daily....

http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=19100

NB their culture is NOT ours! The way they treat woman is NOT our way! Nor is it in India! or 100 other countries! Don't use your US mindset and beliefs to try and understand how they live their life. They have their own culture and in time who knows.........

Even Iran is still fighting to keep their woman down. In some African countries woman are baby makers and that's IT! Travel some! go see some places and you will SEE what the US is so great! You will have to look VERY HARD to find in print stories about what it's like to be a woman in their country.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
greatwhiteelkhunter
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
nuzzlebunny,Nov 22 2007
11:46 AM
Herb,Nov 21 2007
04:43 PM
nuzzlebunny,Nov 21 2007
01:38 PM
greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

Note that it was about the FIRST 25 in the Iraqi army. Note that it didn't happen until 9/04. Had it ever happened before, NO. What did it take to get them the privilege to do this? How about the US overthrow of the repressive regime? How about the example that the women in the US forces set for the Iraqis?

I think having females in combat is great, as the US is finally practicing what it preaches in terms of gender equality in having them there. Leading by example is the best way to lead.

As far as the former regime goes, women were utilized in other ways....

From World Net Daily....

http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=19100

BTW I finally got the article to open. You know what is says to me???

That idiot can do anything he wanted to do even break their laws to accomplish the death of others NOTHING was beyond his power even breaking their laws, using woman and abusing his people as long as it accomplished his goal! self perseverance and wealth!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Toothless Dawg
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Quote:
 
*** the US is finally practicing what it preaches in terms of gender equality in having them there.


Legislating something into law does not make it so. This political correct bull$hit is bringing America to her knees. We need politicians with backbone to stand up to the N.O.W. lezzies and special interest groups and tell them this ain't done in this country because it is harmful to this nation.

I've worked with and for women in my 42 year career and my unit chief now is a woman, as a matter of fact. Two of these women are counted among the best supervisors I have had the pleasure to work for. My unit chief flew choppers for the navy and was a federal prosecutor ... a very intelligent and talented woman. Others rank among the worst bosses in my career but they are ranked alongside males too.

Women instinctively excel in some areas where men don't stand a chance and vice versa. Legislating equality is stupid. Trying to create equality in all things is stupid. Trying to legislate equality on the battlefield is not only stupid but gets people killed.

Besides I don't want anything to do with a woman who doesn't know how to be a lady and I durn sure don't want to have to arm wrestle a woman over a cold beer to get her to wanna pal around.



Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
nuzzlebunny
Unregistered

greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 27 2007
11:40 AM
nuzzlebunny,Nov 21 2007
01:38 PM
greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

When military are out doing the job they do (not in a staged event) and they interact with the common man and his family there is a very deep social status and family oneness that CAN'T be broken. Even just talking to a woman in public is nothing but TROUBLE! It's hard to do some jobs like checking the body for weapons at a check point as one example. What happens on the ground is different then what is reported and I think that is enough said about that!

We really HURT ourselves by breaking their social taboos and men talking to or looking at, Their woman is a TABOO!


My husband says the #1 reason the US isn't getting any where in terms of diplomacy in the ME is that we've had females (Albright back when Clinton was in, now Condi) as Sec. of State and that that part of the world just simply isn't going to listen to a single darn thing a woman has to say. They are cordial and nice to their face, nod their little heads in agreement, then do the exact opposite of what they promised.

Of course, Iran, and especially Saudi Arabia, are probably the worst for treatment of women. As far as the former Iraqi regime goes... who can forget those chicks in that "Most Wanted" deck of cards.... "Dr. Germ" and "Mrs. Anthrax"?

http://www.thenation.com/doc/20060109/scheer1228

Shi'ites in Iraq have a real problem with women (emulating Iran, natch..) , but the former Sunni Ba'athist government had them as high level members of the regime.

Posted Image
Quote Post Goto Top
 
nuzzlebunny
Unregistered

Toothless Dawg,Nov 27 2007
02:02 PM
Quote:
 
*** the US is finally practicing what it preaches in terms of gender equality in having them there.


Legislating something into law does not make it so. This political correct bull$hit is bringing America to her knees. We need politicians with backbone to stand up to the N.O.W. lezzies and special interest groups and tell them this ain't done in this country because it is harmful to this nation.

I've worked with and for women in my 42 year career and my unit chief now is a woman, as a matter of fact. Two of these women are counted among the best supervisors I have had the pleasure to work for. My unit chief flew choppers for the navy and was a federal prosecutor ... a very intelligent and talented woman. Others rank among the worst bosses in my career but they are ranked alongside males too.

Women instinctively excel in some areas where men don't stand a chance and vice versa. Legislating equality is stupid. Trying to create equality in all things is stupid. Trying to legislate equality on the battlefield is not only stupid but gets people killed.

Besides I don't want anything to do with a woman who doesn't know how to be a lady and I durn sure don't want to have to arm wrestle a woman over a cold beer to get her to wanna pal around.


So do you think things would have been smoother in Iraq without the presence of our female troops to deal with situations involving Iraqi women?

Quote Post Goto Top
 
Culture Warrior
Member Avatar
an Angry American
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
I would suggest reading about this young Civil Affairs Female Soldier (courtesy of Michael Yon):

Quote:
 
American Soldiers

Major Mary Prophit led a Civil Affairs team of four that was attached to the Deuce Four in Mosul; she wrote detailed letters home describing events on the ground.

On 18 December, 2004, she wrote:

Quote:
 
This evening I went to the ING [Iraqi National Guard] compound – mainly to coordinate another shopping trip to Dahuk – I am trying to buy heaters and blankets for the poor people with no heat. As always when visiting with Iraqis, there is an art to the conversation – you must “make small talk” — it is expected and polite to converse about little things before getting down to business – our conversations will usually flow from insignificant things, to business and back again. Tonight was no exception. I was able to make more plans to work with the ING to help the Iraqi people – we will help the ING get kerosene to their compound, and then they will share the kerosene with me so I can distribute it to the schools and some poor people.

Anyhow, at one point after being there about an hour and a half, LTC Amar asks if we mind if he asks some questions. He first asked about some of our leaders, mentioning Condoleezza Rice – he asked if in America there is prejudice against African Americans. We said that it is against the law to be prejudiced, however unfortunately there are still some people who feel that way. Then he asked a question that almost brought me to tears. He asked us, “Your freedom, the freedom that you have in America, can you feel it? – is it something you can feel inside of you?” I immediately answered “Yes, I feel it very strongly.”........continued


................

Quote:
 
They had just finished delivering the OIC goods and were driving out to deliver the heaters to other schools when— BOOM!— a bomb ripped through an Iraqi Army truck that was stuffed with about ten men. The truck kept moving, blowing men out and scattering them up and down the road. Four were killed. According to Captain Matt McGrew, who led the ING training, another four were seriously injured. One man lost both hands, one lost a leg and a hand, and another had serious head trauma and lost an eye. In addition to the shrapnel wounds, all had burns, from an attack that was just starting.

The cracks and snaps from small arms fire was coming at the American and Iraqi soldiers. Meanwhile, Recon Platoon and the Commander responded immediately to reinforce. They arrived at the gruesome scene and sporadic firefight, which the CBS and NBC crews were able to record for posterity. Meanwhile, the heaped and tumbled bodies of Iraqi National Guardsmen lay bleeding on the road, while others roasted in the burning truck.

Lt. Col. Kurilla, Deuce Four’s Commander, said later, “Mary performed incredibly under fire and saved Iraqi soldiers’ lives. She did an incredible job of pulling wounded Iraqi soldiers to safety and treating them. Sadly, one of my favorite Iraqi soldiers was killed; we called him Old Blue. He was a Kurdish Peshmerga and had been fighting for more than forty years. Hard as woodpecker lips. I think he was about 55 years old and had 13 children. There was almost nothing left of him.”

The Commander continued, “Mary immediately took charge of the ‘inner circle,’ while First Platoon B Company under Lt. Jaskolski and SSgt. Lundak fought the enemy along with Recon platoon.” Mary dragged at least two Iraqi Army soldiers to safety—under fire—seconds before the ammunition carried in the truck exploded. Mary’s voice can be heard on the video directing American soldiers to get the Iraqi wounded away from the truck. Bullets were flying and rounds were starting to cook off in the fire as she calmly insisted, “this truck’s gonna blow; we need to get the hell out of here.” Moments later, the ammo created the second explosion.

I’d heard other stories about Mary Prophit from soldiers, all of whom held her in highest regard. Mary’s physical courage wasn’t obvious to me when I first met her: she was always disarmingly pleasant and professional whenever we talked. Much later I found out that Mary is a reservist, and her “real job” is Community Library Assistant at Timberland Mountain View Library in Randle, Washington.

In the following weeks and months, Mary and her crew kept rolling out of the gates into the line of fire. While I was in Iraq, it was strange to watch the vigorous debates at home about whether or not women should be allowed in combat. I would think, “don’t they know that our women are in combat here every day?” Major Prophit got into so many firefights that some soldiers dubbed her “the bullet magnet,” while others referred to her as “Major Contact.”



click on link above to read the whole fantastic writing and photography of Michael Yon.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
gobblerblaster
Member Avatar
gobblerblaster
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Well you'll have to excuse me. I say in general, no to women in combat. I know that there are women that have made good soldiers but, I sure wouldn't want either one of my two daughters having to bear this burden that is traditionally "men's work" . Support roles are fine but, as far as women grunts, no way no how. Emotionally we are not equal and in most cases physically we are not equal and I have seen and heard of enough men that came back as basket cases when put under extreme combat conditions, I can just imagine what this will do to the women that are now serving in these units. I know I will be branded a Chauvinist now but, thats OK. I believe GOD made women to be ladies and men to be well ,men. I worked as a hand on a Oil Drilling Rig for 12 years and in my time there I saw a few Women try to handle this very hard labor situation very few where physically able to do this job and the ones that where I sure wouldn't consider ladies......... I know I know, I really stepped in it this time

On second thought, if you could form a battalion of nothing but women with PMS, I think we could take over the better part of the world
:biglol:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Toothless Dawg
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Quote:
 
So do you think things would have been smoother in Iraq without the presence of our female troops to deal with situations involving Iraqi women?


It is far too easy to monday morning quarterback and far too many people do just that. There is no way to say one way or another. What I said was that I knew of many efficient, intelligient, women leaders over the years. I have also known more sorry losers. The same goes for men.

I said that legislating so-called equality does not make it so and that it is stupid to equate military service with equality. I believe that most women are strong enough and intelligient enough to know how to be women and ladies ... a sorry few are not. That sorry few believe they have to serve in war zones, make love on top, play on men's sports teams and belong to the boy scouts.

While women have a long history in war zones (ask any vet who was cared for by a beautiful nurse), I don't believe women should be assigned to units with combat missions. I don't believe women should be firefighters nor should weak men. I don't believe women should be street cops although I know many of them who are just that with one agency or another. I don't believe women should have separate set of requirements to qualify for any job.

Tha's my beliefs and I don't care who doesn't like them ... they are mine!!!

That said, I will not discriminate against any male or female soldier, sailor, airman, marine, coast guard because they are serving our country. I will treat each female law enforcement office with respect due her uniform. I will respect each female that climbs a ladder and barges into a burning building. I will respect ALL women (except mOOnbats, liberals, commies, socialist, anti-american pigs) because they deserve that respect not because they are women, but because I am a gentleman. The mOOnbat, commie, socialist pigs I will NOT respect because I am an American gentleman.

Dawg out ...
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
legitlinda
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
gobblerblaster,Nov 27 2007
03:19 PM
  I worked as a hand on a Oil Drilling Rig for 12 years and in my time there I saw a few Women try to handle this very hard labor situation very few where physically able to do this job and the ones that where I sure wouldn't consider ladies......... I know I know, I really stepped in it this time

On second thought, if you could form a battalion of nothing but women with PMS, I think we could take over the better part of the world
:biglol:


I agree with you guys about women in combat, but if you want to talk about hard labor then that's a job only a woman can do! :P
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Herb
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
gobblerblaster,Nov 27 2007
04:19 PM
On second thought, if you could form a battalion of nothing but women with PMS, I think we could take over the better part of the world
:biglol:

The mugger's worst nightmare.

A woman that just broke up with her boyfriend, with PMS and a .357.

:garfield:
:jus-passin-thru:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Toothless Dawg
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Linda and Herb,

ROFLOL ya'll are too much!!!

:lol: :rotfl: :lol: :rotfl: :lol: :rotfl:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
greatwhiteelkhunter
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
gobblerblaster,Nov 27 2007
04:19 PM
Well you'll have to excuse me. I say in general, no to women in combat. I know that there are women that have made good soldiers but, I sure wouldn't want either one of my two daughters having to bear this burden that is traditionally "men's work" . Support roles are fine but, as far as women grunts, no way no how. Emotionally we are not equal and in most cases physically we are not equal and I have seen and heard of enough men that came back as basket cases when put under extreme combat conditions, I can just imagine what this will do to the women that are now serving in these units. I know I will be branded a Chauvinist now but, thats OK. I believe GOD made women to be ladies and men to be well ,men. I worked as a hand on a Oil Drilling Rig for 12 years and in my time there I saw a few Women try to handle this very hard labor situation very few where physically able to do this job and the ones that where I sure wouldn't consider ladies......... I know I know, I really stepped in it this time

On second thought, if you could form a battalion of nothing but women with PMS, I think we could take over the better part of the world
:biglol:

Hey i agree with you 100%!! We need them in all these support roles and in many ways sending them in with certain kinds of units (I'm speaking from a Marine Corps perspective) is just problems but they really do a good job most of the tme. the FEW that are real problems need to be weeded OUT!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
nuzzlebunny
Unregistered

Toothless Dawg,Nov 27 2007
05:26 PM
Quote:
 
So do you think things would have been smoother in Iraq without the presence of our female troops to deal with situations involving Iraqi women?


It is far too easy to monday morning quarterback and far too many people do just that. There is no way to say one way or another. What I said was that I knew of many efficient, intelligient, women leaders over the years. I have also known more sorry losers. The same goes for men.

I said that legislating so-called equality does not make it so and that it is stupid to equate military service with equality. I believe that most women are strong enough and intelligient enough to know how to be women and ladies ... a sorry few are not. That sorry few believe they have to serve in war zones, make love on top, play on men's sports teams and belong to the boy scouts.

While women have a long history in war zones (ask any vet who was cared for by a beautiful nurse), I don't believe women should be assigned to units with combat missions. I don't believe women should be firefighters nor should weak men. I don't believe women should be street cops although I know many of them who are just that with one agency or another. I don't believe women should have separate set of requirements to qualify for any job.

Tha's my beliefs and I don't care who doesn't like them ... they are mine!!!

That said, I will not discriminate against any male or female soldier, sailor, airman, marine, coast guard because they are serving our country. I will treat each female law enforcement office with respect due her uniform. I will respect each female that climbs a ladder and barges into a burning building. I will respect ALL women (except mOOnbats, liberals, commies, socialist, anti-american pigs) because they deserve that respect not because they are women, but because I am a gentleman. The mOOnbat, commie, socialist pigs I will NOT respect because I am an American gentleman.

Dawg out ...


I feel that the presence of female troops on the front lines in Iraq has been positive. Imagine if they weren't utilized at check points or helping to search homes for insurgents... we are talking about a society where woe betide you if you are male and even touch a woman who isn't your wife! (and in most instances in that part of the world, woe betide the poor woman that got touched).

I'm sure this was a factor in the governments deciding to utilize women in more dangerous roles within the military. It would have been poor planning not to ponder it, and the absence of women to deal with females would have been disastrous.

... :two-cents:
Quote Post Goto Top
 
gobblerblaster
Member Avatar
gobblerblaster
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
legitlinda,Nov 27 2007
05:52 PM
gobblerblaster,Nov 27 2007
03:19 PM
  I worked as a hand on a Oil Drilling Rig for 12 years and in my time there I saw a few Women try to handle this very hard labor situation very few where physically able to do this job and the ones that where I sure wouldn't consider ladies......... I know I know, I really stepped in it this time

On second thought, if you could form a battalion of nothing but women with PMS, I think we could take over the better part of the world
:biglol:


I agree with you guys about women in combat, but if you want to talk about hard labor then that's a job only a woman can do! :P

I'll tell ya what Linda, I can out work any woman on the face of the earth and my wife would back me up if she where here but, she is out digging a well and after that she is going to build fence across the south pasture so when she gets lose I'll have her give ya a hollar.

:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Culture Warrior
Member Avatar
an Angry American
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
gobblerblaster,Nov 27 2007
04:19 PM
Well you'll have to excuse me. I say in general, no to women in combat. I know that there are women that have made good soldiers but, I sure wouldn't want either one of my two daughters having to bear this burden that is traditionally "men's work" . Support roles are fine but, as far as women grunts, no way no how. Emotionally we are not equal and in most cases physically we are not equal and I have seen and heard of enough men that came back as basket cases when put under extreme combat conditions, I can just imagine what this will do to the women that are now serving in these units. I know I will be branded a Chauvinist  now but, thats OK. I believe GOD made women to be ladies and men to be  well ,men. I worked as a hand on a Oil Drilling Rig for 12 years and in my time there I saw a few Women try to handle this very hard labor situation very few where physically able to do this job and the ones that where I sure wouldn't consider ladies......... I know I know, I really stepped in it this time

On second thought, if you could form a battalion of nothing but women with PMS, I think we could take over the better part of the world
:biglol:

I beg to differ on your opinion.....I know a few young female soldiers that just may be able to kick your ars :D even without PMS :P


From the point of CA's (read article I pointed out above) their presence is beyond crucial - it is detrimental to success!

The original point of this subject is "Women in Combat"

Make a woman an infantryman - probably not a good idea, but I'd put money that there are women that would do their damnest to prove they can be, and probably could be.

But, put a women in a chopper (not much different than combat) and we all know that there are some dang good women pilots out there.

Put a women in the MP position (which you absolutely MUST do to prevent a bunch of P'd off bees from being even more P'd off). AND to help assist training female ISF. Now, how often does anyone in a MP position see combat? Probably dang near as much as the infantryman.

Now, let's go up to the CA soldier - Major Prophit, above. These CA's have to be in the field in order to be effective. They MUST be face to face with the people. Now what do you think that does? These CA soldiers are not only trying to get the job done rebuilding the country face to face with the people of that country - they must also keep the corner of their eye open to look out for the terrorist sniper trying to stop them from doing their job. AND the IED's that are out there waiting for their convoy to go by as they go on basically a peaceful mission to aid civilians. Is she in combat? Don't believe any of this? I've been at a briefing that showed more than you would want to see......I'll leave it at that.

We can sit and argue up and down as to whether women should be in combat, but unfortunately today's warfare puts ALL of our brave young men AND women in combat. In harm's way.

TD - thanks for the great pic - whenever I see these pics, it just puts a chill up your spine and pride in your heart! smiley-patriotic-flag-wave

good nite all - I have one hell of a few days ahead........and so do some Families.

CW out for a few days.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
nuzzlebunny
Unregistered

greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 27 2007
11:54 AM
nuzzlebunny,Nov 22 2007
11:46 AM
Herb,Nov 21 2007
04:43 PM
nuzzlebunny,Nov 21 2007
01:38 PM
greatwhiteelkhunter,Nov 21 2007
01:31 AM
Well I have alot of options about this and in the past they were all BAD!  It's not that way any longer for alot of reasons I'll not go into.

Bottom line here is this.  Challenging at times? YES, work? yes, are they doing a good job? yes, and on top of all this they have a unique status in Iraq and we NEED them in Iraq if were going to get to where we need to in the end.  A man ANY man dealing with the Iraqi woman is NOTHING but trouble.  We need these females to do the jobs they are doing.

He(( look at the expression of the kid in the picture.  He looks like that because woman there wold NEVER be in that role EVER!  Might as well be looking at a 3 headed dragon as far as he is concerned!

They do a good job


Never? From 2004.....

http://www.defendamerica.mil/articles/sep2004/a093004a.html

Note that it was about the FIRST 25 in the Iraqi army. Note that it didn't happen until 9/04. Had it ever happened before, NO. What did it take to get them the privilege to do this? How about the US overthrow of the repressive regime? How about the example that the women in the US forces set for the Iraqis?

I think having females in combat is great, as the US is finally practicing what it preaches in terms of gender equality in having them there. Leading by example is the best way to lead.

As far as the former regime goes, women were utilized in other ways....

From World Net Daily....

http://www.wnd.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=19100

BTW I finally got the article to open. You know what is says to me???

That idiot can do anything he wanted to do even break their laws to accomplish the death of others NOTHING was beyond his power even breaking their laws, using woman and abusing his people as long as it accomplished his goal! self perseverance and wealth!

When you say breaking "their laws" are you referring to that horrid Sharia Law?
Quote Post Goto Top
 
gobblerblaster
Member Avatar
gobblerblaster
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]
Culture Warrior,Nov 27 2007
11:13 PM

:biglol:

I beg to differ on your opinion.....I know a few young female soldiers that just may be able to kick your ars :D even without PMS :P


[/QUOTE]
Ain't no way on this Earth, My wife is going to let any she-male hurt her wittle cuttlebug
:garfield:
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
VMI84

Moderator
When I was a Company Commander I had a female First Sergeant and she was good. She could max her PT test and the best part of it was she hated female soldiers who whined and tried to get get over by claiming female issues. She considered it a slap at her achievements. She was good and would jerk a knot in their chains when they tried.
On another note I have a beautiful daughter :) who's mother wears combat boots and has more awards and decorations on her uniform than I do to include a combat patch. She is also my wife.
Lets also not forget the young lady MP who won the Silver Star when her convoy was attacked. In the process the sent several of those "peaceful goat herders" to the promised land. smiley-bouncin Some can do it and some cannot.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Toothless Dawg
Member Avatar
Ruler of the Mountain
[ *  *  *  *  *  *  * ]

Here is a video of a woman marine in training ... my durn face is still burning from the shot she takes ... OoooRAH!!!



Get Some
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · The Front Porch · Next Topic »
Add Reply