Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
    Welcome to Nintendo Forums. We hope you enjoy your visit.


    You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


    Join our community!


    If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

    Username:   Password:
    Add Reply
    • Pages:
    • 1
    Sonic vs Mario
    Sonic 10 (55.6%)
    Mario 5 (27.8%)
    Draw 3 (16.7%)
    Total Votes: 18
    Sonic vs Mario
    Topic Started: Jun 18 2005, 04:00 PM (455 Views)
    caleb_brehaut
    Goomba
    I know that this has been done many times before but with so many members now, I thought it might be interesting to know. Now I'm talking cross over fight here not which game do you prefer, just to get that straight, as considering it's a nintendo forum, Sonic would get slaughtered. So I decided to make it more interesting, instead of just Sonic Vs Mario, how about Sonic and his friends/enemies vs Mario and his friends/enemies. just go with me here! It would be interesting if instead of just your opinion of who would win you stated why and possibly even a match report. So here's the match ups:
    Sonic vs Mario (duh!)
    Tails vs Luigi
    Knuckles vs Toad
    Princess Peach vs Amy
    Big the Cat vs Yoshi
    Bowser vs Dr Robotnik
    Shadow vs Wario
    Donkey Kong vs Rouge

    Match 1 - Sonic vs Mario
    Sonic dashes at Mario. Mario falls over. The end.
    Victor - Sonic

    Match 2 - Tails vs Luigi
    Tails looks up at Luigi and faints from vertigo.
    Victor - Luigi

    Match 3 - Knuckles vs Toad
    Knuckles punches Toad. Toad faints.
    Victor - Knuckles

    Match 4 - Princess Peach vs Amy
    Amy hits Peach over the head with one her trademark hammers and Peach is knocked out.
    Victor - Amy

    Match 5 - Big the Cat vs Yoshi
    Yoshi eats Big's best friend Froggy and Big goes crazy hitting Yoshi over the head with his fishing rod. Yoshi then summons some friends and they all kick Big's head in.
    Victor - Yoshi

    Match 6 - Bowser vs Eggman
    Eggman launches missiles from his egg mobile and Bowser simply shrugs them off and rips Eggman from his craft. He then begins to burn Eggman but the fat in Eggmans body combusts and blows them both up.
    Victor - None

    Match 7 - Shadow vs Wario
    Shadow spin dashes Wario only to rebound off him. Shadow then, taking up a chaos emerald, uses Chaos Control to teleport to the top of a hill. By the time Wario makes it up the hill he collapses from exhaustion.
    Victor - Shadow

    Match 8 - Donkey Kong vs Rouge
    Rouge unleashes a flurry of kicks on DK but he barely notices them. He grabs her and takes her to the top of a tall building and lobs barrels down at Knuckles for attempting to rescue her by climbing the building. He gives up, realising he never really liked her anyway.
    Victor - Donkey Kong

    Humour me!
    Posted Image
    ^Sig by (the almighty) Zaneblade
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    Stu_J
    Member Avatar
    Kirby
    thinkyou gt it all pretty spot on caleb mate, defo with sonic I mean as a fan of both sega and ninty I cn be unbias, but sonic wood stuff mario at fighting, at sports however thts a different story cus mario cn play footie now :D
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    caleb_brehaut
    Goomba
    So can Sonic! He appears in some of the Virtua Striker games in hidden team with other Sonic characters and haven't you seen the mcdonalds advert about the happy meal with the sega toys. Beautiful goal! :D
    Posted Image
    ^Sig by (the almighty) Zaneblade
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    C-MarioNLuigi
    Member Avatar
    Call me "CMNL".......
    Sonic has 1 thing, Speed.
    After that, Sonic is nothing, nothing at all, just a hedgehog.

    Mario wins because
    -He is simply more skilled, he's been saving peach for over 10 years.
    -His powerups are far superior to that of Sonics
    -His Friends (teammates) are so much more superior then that of Sonics that it's not a competition (well maybe Knuckles)

    Mario wins, simple.
    And to be truthful, the majority of Marios Enemies could probably take Sonic.
    ~Yee~
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    caleb_brehaut
    Goomba
    What has Mario got? Clogged arteries and a face that only his mother could love! He's just an ordinary guy but Sonic is superhuman! (well about as superhuman as a hedgehog can be!)

    In reply to your reasons (not that I trying to deny you your opinions but I have to correct grave injustices!):
    -Ok, Mario is more skilled? He's been sitting on people for over ten years! Sonic can grind, swing and touch his toes. Which is much more than Mario can do!
    -His powerups are better? Which ones are refering to here, his 2D or 3D ones? But how can anything be better than Super Sonic? Particularly in the 2D games!
    -Are you honestly telling me that Peach could beat Amy in a fight? Or did you just forget that? Plus there's all sorts of Sonic characters not mentioned here: Chaotix, Chaos, the many Metal Sonics and E series! (Mighty of Chaotix is stronger than even Knuckles!)

    Bowser against Sonic? Sounds interesting! But Sonic could take out Bowser, DK and Wario simultanously! He can run faster than Mach 1 and is a highly skilled acrobat and so they'd never be able to even strike him! All it takes is seven chaos emeralds...
    Posted Image
    ^Sig by (the almighty) Zaneblade
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    REALiTY
    Member Avatar
    Lurking moar.
    Sonic would whoop Mario. But I also think that Wario could take Shadow. He may be fat, but his "herculean strength" (SSBM) would be way too much for Shadow. One shoulder check and he's outta here :D.
    Posted Image
    Why do I post so little? I'm scared I'll lose my purple username.
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    Zimoshi
    Member Avatar
    Krystal
    sonic vs mario...it's obvious that sonic would win.I vote sonic.
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    THE_AUSTRALIAN_GUY
    Member Avatar
    Koopa
    Mario is a plumber, Sonic can make a sonic boom right? :P must I say more?
    1111111110000000110000000011111111
    111111111
    0000001111000000011100000
    0001110000000011111100000011100000
    0001110000000110000110000011100011
    0001110000000111111110000011100011
    0001110000000110000110000011100011
    0001110000000110000110000011111111
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    Sontailsic
    Member Avatar
    Chelsea FC Champions 55-05-06-10

    *shreiks* Never make me pick between these two, NEVER!

    Posted Image
    Posted Image
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    caleb_brehaut
    Goomba
    I think the mario side is considerably underspoken here! :D . There's been people voting 4 mario and yet only C-00-TheBowser has spoken out (only to get knocked back down again! :P ). Are Mario supporters afraid of something? it's possible... :yes:

    P.s. Zork, I actually think your right after thinkin it over! Shadow couldn't really do much against Wario as he is virtually immune 2 all but the strongest attacks. (and cause he wasn't much of a match 4 Sonic!)
    Posted Image
    ^Sig by (the almighty) Zaneblade
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    MP1
    Living in Vandy Land
    Yeah, Sonic would win.... But... There is a small chance that Mario could win... He'd have to hurl fireballs like mad at sonic and dodge all of sonics movements. That's the only way.
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    REALiTY
    Member Avatar
    Lurking moar.
    caleb_brehaut
    Jun 25 2005, 05:31 PM
    P.s. Zork, I actually think your right after thinkin it over! Shadow couldn't really do much against Wario as he is virtually immune 2 all but the strongest attacks. (and cause he wasn't much of a match 4 Sonic!)

    Yep... he was described as "the invincible Wario" in Wario lands II and 3.
    Posted Image
    Why do I post so little? I'm scared I'll lose my purple username.
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    Stu_J
    Member Avatar
    Kirby
    caleb_brehaut
    Jun 25 2005, 05:31 PM
    I think the mario side is considerably underspoken here! :D . There's been people voting 4 mario and yet only C-00-TheBowser has spoken out (only to get knocked back down again! :P ). Are Mario supporters afraid of something? it's possible... :yes:

    P.s. Zork, I actually think your right after thinkin it over! Shadow couldn't really do much against Wario as he is virtually immune 2 all but the strongest attacks. (and cause he wasn't much of a match 4 Sonic!)

    you all seem to be forgettin one thing CHAOS CONTROL!! shadow cood use this to pwn wario, I mean c'mon BANG! he's behindyou WHACK! out like a light. I think the mario side needs to be voiced, he is a true hero, and he shows the love, to luigi and peach look how sonic treats tails and amy and knuckles. Mario does have gadgets too FLUDD cood be used very skillfully make sonic slip on his blue behind, and lets nt forget sonic cnt swim!
    P.S I still think sonic wood win normally but in specail cases I dunno
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    Dark Warrior Safiullah
    Toadette
    sonic would win, a team of elite fighters versus a plumber, his easily kidnapped girlfriend, his brother, a monster that is obsessed with capturing peach, some fat dude, and a gorilla. The only good people are donkey kong and bowser, but bowser is man dumb, but donkey kong can fight good. Donkey should quit the team :mad: !
    I Need A Sig
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    caleb_brehaut
    Goomba
    The only possible way that Shadow could win would be by changing into Super Shadow (or Hyper Shadow depending on which source you believe!). Chaos Control could only be used to run away after Wario beats him badly! As for Sonic treating them badly how would you feel if you had a camp fox and an annoying fan clinging 2you all the time! :mad: And Knuckles deserves what he gets, he's so gullible! :D
    Posted Image
    ^Sig by (the almighty) Zaneblade
    Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
     
    1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
    Go to Next Page
    « Previous Topic · Off-Topic Chat · Next Topic »
    Add Reply
    • Pages:
    • 1